| American Toad | Anaxyrus | americanus americanus | | 2 | Amphibians | Bufonidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Fowler's Toad | Anaxyrus | fowleri | | 2 | Amphibians | Bufonidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Cricket Frog | Acris | crepitans crepitans | | 1 | Amphibians | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Cope's Gray Treefrog | Hyla | chrysoscelis | | 1 | Amphibians | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Spring Peeper | Pseudacris | crucifer crucifer | | 1 | Amphibians | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Upland Chorus Frog | Pseudacris | feriarum | | 1 | Amphibians | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| New Jersey Chorus Frog | Pseudacris | kalmi | | 1 | Amphibians | Hylidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Wood Frog | Lithobates | sylvaticus | | 1 | Amphibians | Ranidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Spadefoot | Scaphiopus | holbrookii | | 1 | Amphibians | Scaphiopodidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Spotted Salamander | Ambystoma | maculatum | | 3 | Amphibians | Ambystomatidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Marbled Salamander | Ambystoma | opacum | | 3 | Amphibians | Ambystomatidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Tiger Salamander | Ambystoma | tigrinum | | 1 | Amphibians | Ambystomatidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Dusky Salamander | Desmognathus | fuscus | | 3 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Allegheny Mountain Dusky Salamander | Desmognathus | ochrophaeus | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Two-lined Salamander | Eurycea | bislineata | | 2 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Long-tailed Salamander | Eurycea | longicauda longicauda | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Spring Salamander | Gyrinophilus | porphyriticus | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Four-toed Salamander | Hemidactylium | scutatum | | 3 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Red-backed Salamander | Plethodon | cinereus | | 2 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Slimy Salamander | Plethodon | glutinosus | | 3 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Valley and Ridge Salamander | Plethodon | hoffmani | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Mud Salamander | Pseudotriton | montanus | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Red Salamander | Pseudotriton | ruber | | 2 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Newt | Notophthalmus | viridescens | | 3 | Amphibians | Salamandridae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Hadrobunus | maculosus | | 1 | Harvestmen | Sclerosomatidae | Opiliones | Arachnida | Animalia |
| Merlin | Falco | columbarius | | 1 | Birds | Falconidae | Falconiformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Song Sparrow | Melospiza | melodia | | 1 | Birds | Emberizidae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Brown-headed Cowbird | Molothrus | ater | | 1 | Birds | Icteridae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Shiny Cowbird | Molothrus | bonariensis | | 1 | Birds | Icteridae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| House Sparrow | Passer | domesticus | | 1 | Birds | Passeridae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Pileated Woodpecker | Dryocopus | pileatus | | 1 | Birds | Picidae | Piciformes | Aves | Animalia |
| No Common Name | Scolopocryptops | peregrinator | | 1 | Centipedes | Scolopocryptopidae | Scolopendromorpha | Chilopoda | Animalia |
| Eastern Wormsnake | Carphophis | amoenus amoenus | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Northern Black Racer | Coluber | constrictor constrictor | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Ring-necked Snake | Diadophis | punctatus | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Rainbow Snake | Farancia | erytrogramma erytrogramma | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Hog-nosed Snake | Heterodon | platirhinos | | 3 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Kingsnake | Lampropeltis | getula | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Northern Mole Kingsnake | Lampropeltis | rhombomaculata | | 5 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Milksnake | Lampropeltis | triangulum triangulum | | 7 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Ratsnake | Pantherophis | alleghaniensis | | 2 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Pinesnake | Pituophis | melanoleucus | | 2 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Queen Snake | Regina | septemvittata | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Dekay's Brownsnake | Storeria | dekayi | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Red-bellied Snake | Storeria | occipitomaculata | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Ribbonsnake | Thamnophis | saurita | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Common Gartersnake | Thamnophis | sirtalis | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Smooth Earthsnake | Virginia | valeriae valeriae | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Copperhead | Agkistrodon | contortrix | | 2 | Reptiles | Crotalidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Fence Lizard | Sceloporus | undulatus | | 1 | Reptiles | Phrynosomatidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Common Five-lined Skink | Plestiodon | fasciatus | | 2 | Reptiles | Scincidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Six-lined Racerunner | Aspidoscelis | sexlineatus | | 1 | Reptiles | Teiidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Painted Turtle | Chrysemys | picta picta | | 1 | Reptiles | Emydidae | Testudines | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene | carolina carolina | | 5 | Reptiles | Emydidae | Testudines | Reptilia | Animalia |