| Spotted Salamander | Ambystoma | maculatum | | 2 | Amphibians | Ambystomatidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Marbled Salamander | Ambystoma | opacum | | 1 | Amphibians | Ambystomatidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Dusky Salamander | Desmognathus | fuscus | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Two-lined Salamander | Eurycea | bislineata | | 3 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Red Salamander | Pseudotriton | ruber | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eastern Newt | Notophthalmus | viridescens | | 1 | Amphibians | Salamandridae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Eyed Click Beetle | Alaus | oculatus | | 1 | Click Beetles | Elateridae | Coleoptera | Insecta | Animalia |
| Eastern Wormsnake | Carphophis | amoenus amoenus | | 0 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Ring-necked Snake | Diadophis | punctatus | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Hog-nosed Snake | Heterodon | platirhinos | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Ratsnake | Pantherophis | alleghaniensis | | 4 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Dekay's Brownsnake | Storeria | dekayi | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Common Gartersnake | Thamnophis | sirtalis | | 3 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Fence Lizard | Sceloporus | undulatus | | 2 | Reptiles | Phrynosomatidae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |
| Eastern Box Turtle | Terrapene | carolina carolina | | 0 | Reptiles | Emydidae | Testudines | Reptilia | Animalia |