| Golden Shiner | Notemigonus | crysoleucas | | 1 | Fish | Cyprinidae | Cypriniformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Northern Pike | Esox | lucius | | 1 | Fish | Esocidae | Esociformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Chain Pickerel | Esox | niger | | 1 | Fish | Esocidae | Esociformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Smallmouth Bass | Micropterus | dolomieu | | 1 | Fish | Centrarchidae | Perciformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Largemouth Bass | Micropterus | nigricans | | 1 | Fish | Centrarchidae | Perciformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Yellow Perch | Perca | flavescens | | 1 | Fish | Percidae | Perciformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Walleye | Sander | vitreus | | 1 | Fish | Percidae | Perciformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| Brook Trout | Salvelinus | fontinalis | | 1 | Fish | Salmonidae | Salmoniformes | Actinopterygii | Animalia |
| American Toad | Anaxyrus | americanus americanus | | 1 | Amphibians | Bufonidae | Anura | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Allegheny Mountain Dusky Salamander | Desmognathus | ochrophaeus | | 1 | Amphibians | Plethodontidae | Caudata | Amphibia | Animalia |
| Northern Pintail | Anas | acuta | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Snow Goose | Anser | caerulescens | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Bufflehead | Bucephala | albeola | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Hooded Merganser | Lophodytes | cucullatus | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| American Wigeon | Mareca | americana | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Common Merganser | Mergus | merganser | | 1 | Birds | Anatidae | Anseriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Rock Pigeon | Columba | livia | | 1 | Birds | Columbidae | Columbiformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Northern Cardinal | Cardinalis | cardinalis | | 1 | Birds | Cardinalidae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Dark-eyed Junco (Slate-colored) | Junco | hyemalis | | 1 | Birds | Emberizidae | Passeriformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Northern Saw-whet Owl | Aegolius | acadicus | | 1 | Birds | Strigidae | Strigiformes | Aves | Animalia |
| Black Bear | Ursus | americanus | | 0 | Mammals | Ursidae | Carnivora | Mammalia | Animalia |
| Eastern Cottontail | Sylvilagus | floridanus | | 1 | Mammals | Leporidae | Lagomorpha | Mammalia | Animalia |
| Feral Horse | Equus | caballus | | 1 | Mammals | Equidae | Perissodactyla | Mammalia | Animalia |
| North American Porcupine | Erethizon | dorsatus | | 0 | Mammals | Erethizontidae | Rodentia | Mammalia | Animalia |
| Eastern Chipmunk | Tamias | striatus | | 1 | Mammals | Sciuridae | Rodentia | Mammalia | Animalia |
| Ring-necked Snake | Diadophis | punctatus | | 1 | Reptiles | Colubridae | Squamata | Reptilia | Animalia |